The allegation claims the Prophet's marriages were driven only by desire.
The ResponseIslamic scholarship does not treat the Prophet's marriages as disconnected anecdotes. They are read against the social realities of widowhood, tribal reconciliation, legal instruction, and the burdens of leadership in a rapidly changing community.
A fair reading also begins with proportion. For many years the Prophet remained in a single marriage with Khadijah. Later marriages happened in a different phase of life, under different communal conditions, and often carried responsibilities larger than private companionship alone.